Category: Statistics

Reading the SPC IP Court’s 2025 Annual Report: Data, Composition, and Reporting Structure

This post examines the SPC IP Court’s 2025 Annual Report by focusing on underlying data, case composition, and reporting structure rather than headline claims. It shows that foreign participation is concentrated in administrative appeals, that punitive damages and trade secret cases remain a small share of the docket, and that plant variety protection is receiving increased attention. The post argues that careful attention to denominators, omissions, and how data are presented is necessary to understand what the report actually shows.

Comparing the Metrics on China and Intellectual Property

China’s success in meeting IP-related metrics highlights a broader challenge for comparative ranking systems: they often measure what is easiest to quantify—such as patent and trademark filings—rather than how IP systems actually function in practice. While China has shifted from quantity to “quality”-oriented indicators, these remain metric-driven and closely tied to national planning goals, including commercialization, industrial output, and global portfolio development. By contrast, indices like the U.S. Chamber’s International IP Index and the World Justice Project emphasize legal and institutional conditions, but may underweight how effectively private rights are enforced in real-world settings. A more balanced approach would focus on the operation of civil remedies, transparency across all forms of enforcement, treatment of foreign and domestic actors, the functioning of private licensing markets, and the system’s responsiveness to new technologies—areas that are harder to quantify but more indicative of a well-functioning IP system.

Seeking Truth Through Facts in Innovation & US-China Relations

A brief essay that reflects on the meaning of “seeking truth through facts” (实事求是) as both a classical Chinese scholarly method and a contemporary challenge in U.S.–China policy discourse. Drawing on its origins in the Book of Han, its later use by Mao Zedong and Deng Xiaoping, and my own experience moderating an Asia Society program on innovation, the piece explores how facts are often distorted by politics, emotion, and narrative convenience. Using examples from intellectual property debates and the misuse of statistics, it argues that factual rigor remains indispensable, especially when facts challenge deeply held beliefs.

Patent Litigation, IP Monetization and Technology Decoupling: Lessons for the Future

Even during a time of trade conflict, there was considerable litigation and patent licensing activity with China, including a pronounced role in global markets for Chinese companies and in China for US companies. Patent disputes and licensing involved a diverse group of technologies. Chinese companies have become more active in SEP litigation overseas. The United States is an important venue for litigating overseas patent disputes with Chinese entities. Both the patent licensing and pharma data show the importance of tracking market value and trends to determine the real-world impact of IP-related policies.